CRITICAL APPRAISAL OF A SYSTEMATIC REVIEW AND NARRATIVE...

CRITICAL APPRAISAL OF A SYSTEMATIC REVIEW AND NARRATIVE REVIEW RELATED TO COMPUTERISED PHYSICIAN ORDER ENTRY SYSTEM The author of this paper is a nurse educator working in an Intensive Care Unit (ICU) within the north-west region of England. For the purpose of this paper, the author has chosen a systematic review (SR) and a narrative review (NR) and aims to critically analyse these reviews using the Critical Appraisal Skills Programme (CASP) tool. The CASP tool has been developed by the Solutions for Public Health (SPH) (formerly known as Public Health Resources Unit), which is controlled by the National Health Service (NHS) (SPH, 2006). The tool is based on the guidelines formed by a group of clinicians at McMaster University, Canada†¦show more content†¦The author feels that using two different tools would increase the rigour of the appraisal and its relevance to practice. In the forthcoming sections of this essay, the author will attempt critically analyse the two papers using the CASP tool for SRs. Formulation of the research question Formulation of the research question guides the type of data collection for the study and states what the study will ‘hypothesise’ (Polit and Beck, 2010). The CASP tool acknowledges that clearly-focused research question will describe the population studied, the intervention given and the outcomes considered (SPH, 2006). The research question in the SR is clearly formulated. The population of patients studied were general and critically ill hospital patients, the intervention was a SR and outcome to be assessed was about the safety of the CPOE and clinical decision support systems or CDSS (CDSS is a computerised medication prescription system) based on hierarchy of outcome measures (kindly refer to table 2 of SR) within ICU settings. Likewise, in the NR, the population of patients studied were general and critically ill patients, the analysis was done via a NR and the purpose of the study was to assess the results of CPOE on clinical and surrogate outcomes in hospitalise d patients in both general and critical care settings. Based on this, the author acknowledges that the SR has adopted a narrow and more specific research question asShow MoreRelatedEvidence Based Practice Essay6286 Words   |  26 Pagesapproximately 17 hears to translate research findings into practice (if at all) • Without current best evidence, practice becomes rapidly out of date to the detriment of patients. • In order to keep up with the journals relevant to our practice, we need to review 19 articles a day, 365 days of the year!!! • Textbooks may be out of date by the time they are printed • Traditional continuing education conferences do not significannot ly improve clinical practice. • To advance our profession and enhance lifeRead MoreDeveloping a framework for critiquing health research5723 Words   |  23 Pagesthat are commonly used to critique qualitative research and then presents a single framework that addresses both research approaches. This new framework is currently being used to assist teaching and learning activities relating to the critical appraisal of published research. As such, it is still in the developmental stage and as teachers we continue to reflect on the application of this framework to our teaching. Feedback from students is essential to this development and the article presentsRead MoreThe Difference between Performance Management and Performance Appraisal24271 Words   |  98 Pages Performance Management and Appraisal Learning Outcomes After studying this chapter you should be able to: 8.1 Discuss the difference between performance management and performance appraisal 8.2 Identify the necessary characteristics of accurate performance management tools 8.3 List and briefly discuss the purposes for performance appraisals 8.4 Identify and briefly discuss the options for â€Å"what† is evaluated in a performance appraisal 8.5 Briefly discuss the commonlyRead MorePerformance Appraisal17716 Words   |  71 PagesSpecially Uploaded for ProjectsParadise.com PERFORMANCE APPRAISAL SYSTEM -1- Specially Uploaded for ProjectsParadise.com INDEX SR.NO 1. TOPIC MEASURING PERFORMANCE V/S ACTION PERFORMANCE APPRAISAL OBJECTIVES OF PERFORMANCE APPRAISAL PERFORMANCE APPRAISAL AND COMPETITIVE ADVANTAGE APPRAISAL PROCESS METHODS OF APPRAISAL MANAGEMENT BY BJECTIVES(MBO) LARSEN AND TOUBRO, HUMAN RESOURCE DEVELOPMENT— PERFORMANCE APPRAISAL SYSTEM ASSESSMENT CENTRES 360-DEGREE FEEDBACK APPRAISE THE PERFORMANCERead MoreStudy Guide Essay25129 Words   |  101 Pagesany information storage and retrieval system without written permission from the publisher, except for the inclusion of brief quotation in review. Copyright  © 2014 by California Coast University BAM 411 Human Resource Management Syllabus Course Number BAM 411 Course Title Human Resource Management Course Description This course provides a thorough review of essential human resource management concepts and techniques. Current research and developments in the field are covered and trends inRead MoreSmart Home Technology10920 Words   |  44 PagesSmart technologies for older people a systematic literature review of smart technologies that promote health and wellbeing of older people living at home www.broadband.unimelb.edu.au May 2012 Authors Meg Morris, PhD Chair Physiotherapy, The University of Melbourne Elizabeth Ozanne, PhD Associate Professor, Social Work, The University of Melbourne Kim Miller, PhD Senior Lecturer Physiotherapy, The University of Melbourne Nick Santamaria, PhD Chair Translational Nursing, The University ofRead MoreImpooving Employee Performance72019 Words   |  289 PagesIMPROVING EMPLOYEE PERFORMANCE THROUGH APPRAISAL AND COACHING Second Edition IMPROVING EMPLOYEE PERFORMANCE THROUGH APPRAISAL AND COACHING Second Edition Donald L. Kirkpatrick Foreword by Dick Grote American Management Association New York †¢ Atlanta †¢ Brussels †¢ Chicago †¢ Mexico City †¢ San Francisco Shanghai †¢ Tokyo †¢ Toronto †¢ Washington, D.C. Special discounts on bulk quantities of AMACOM books are available to corporations, professional associationsRead MoreA Needs Assessment Survey in a Gastroenterology Endoscopy Community of Practice12128 Words   |  49 Pagespractice (CoP) might provide knowledge sharing and professional networking opportunities for NP and PA colonoscopists, based on assessment of their need for professional activities. A critical appraisal of related literature pointed out key motivational and structural elements of CoPs. Content experts will review the draft survey and the revised survey will be piloted with several non-physician colonoscopists. Using snowball sampling, a needs assessment survey will be conducted to determine if credentialedRead MoreEssay on Research In Clinical Practise8128 Words   |  33 Pagesaetiology of leg ulceration to more recent developments, such as dedicated leg ulcer clinics (Dowsett, 2004). However, it is a concern that leg ulcer clinics are being justified by nurses and organizations based on uncontrolled studies and narrative accounts (Bosanquet et al, 1993; Fletcher, 1995; Stevens et al, 1997; Thorne, 1998; Audit Commission, 1999). It has been widely suggested that the establishment of community leg ulcer clinics could increase healing rates for leg ulcersRead MoreThe Impact of Economic Meltdown on the Nigeria Banking Industry (a Case Study of Intercontinental Bank Plc).13502 Words   |  55 Pagesmeltdown originating from unsecured credits and poor bank management in the Nigerian commercial banking system) as a benchmark to analyze the effects. Data was collected from journals, interviews and direct data from specific units of the bank. The appraisal of the staff of Intercontinental Bank was used to assess performance under the first hypothesis. The second hypothesis tends to seek the staff opinion on effects of policy changes in the system and their performance. The study suggests that the economy